So, this project has taken up the vast majority of my Day Job for the last year or so. We're finally approaching the point where a decision can be made on which LMS we'll be using.
I just published our working group's report on the project website, so we can share the current data with the university community. Long story short, it's a draw between Canvas and D2L, with further information needed before Those Who Are Higher Up Than I Am can make the decision. Good times.